Pakistan’s Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) has approved the export of another 416,000 metric tonnes of sugar, bringing the total quantity authorised for export during the current season to 724,000 tonnes. The decision comes despite the government’s failure to fulfil an International Monetary Fund (IMF) condition requiring the complete deregulation of the sugar sector.
Federal Minister for National Food Security Rana Tanveer Hussain confirmed the decision to The Express Tribune following an ECC meeting on Friday. He said the sugarcane crushing season was about to begin and there was no shortage of sugar in the country.
The latest approval is the third permission granted for sugar exports in four months and has raised questions about government intervention, transparency and the potential impact on domestic consumers and farmers.
ECC Approves Additional Sugar Export Quota
The Cabinet Committee on Export of Sugar had recommended allowing the export of 400,000 metric tonnes of sugar. It also proposed an additional allocation of 16,000 tonnes for Sindh, taking the total approved quantity to 416,000 tonnes.
The government had previously authorised the export of 108,000 tonnes of imported sugar in August and another 200,000 tonnes of locally produced sugar in September.
With the latest decision, the total quantity approved for export during the current season has reached 724,000 metric tonnes.
An industry representative told The Express Tribune that an in-principle decision to export 600,000 tonnes had been taken several months earlier but was implemented in phases to avoid public attention.
The report also stated that the latest sugar export summary was presented as an additional agenda item rather than being included in the ECC’s regular agenda. It was not circulated among the relevant ministries beforehand, limiting their opportunity to examine and comment on the proposal.
IMF Condition for Sugar Sector Deregulation Remains Unfulfilled
The export approval comes as Pakistan continues to face an unresolved condition from the International Monetary Fund requiring complete deregulation of the sugar sector.
Under the proposed reforms, the government is expected to withdraw from directly controlling sugar imports and exports, allowing market forces to determine trade decisions.
However, the condition remains unmet. Finance Secretary Imdadullah Bosal reportedly attributed the delay to the refusal of one province to accept the proposed changes.
Finance Minister Muhammad Aurangzeb also emphasised the importance of deregulating the sector during the ECC meeting, even as the committee approved another export quota.
The decision was taken shortly before an IMF executive board meeting scheduled to consider Pakistan’s request for a $1 billion tranche under its structural reform programme, along with $200 million under the climate financing facility.
Pakistan’s Sugar Industry Faces Structural Challenges
According to the government’s draft National Policy for Deregulation of the Sugar Sector, Pakistan has 79 sugar processing mills located mainly in southern Punjab, northern and central Sindh, and southern Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa.
The country produces an average of approximately 6.13 million tonnes of refined sugar annually, making it the world’s seventh-largest producer.
However, the draft policy identifies several structural problems, including government-controlled prices, zoning restrictions and discretionary trade policies.
These interventions have affected market incentives and contributed to production and pricing instability, with sugar mills operating at approximately 60 per cent of their installed capacity.
Pakistan produced around 5.8 million tonnes of sugar during the previous year, while domestic consumption stood at approximately 6.3 million tonnes.
The draft policy also estimates that sugar millers earned around $1.6 billion through exports over the past decade. During the same period, Pakistan exported approximately 3.92 million tonnes of sugar and imported around 565,000 tonnes.
Potential Sugar Price Surge: Alleged New Cartel Emerges in Pakistan’s Sugar Sector
Sugar Prices and Domestic Consumers Remain a Concern
Despite Pakistan’s significant sugar production, domestic retail prices have experienced considerable volatility.
According to figures cited by the Ministry of Industries, retail sugar prices increased by an average of approximately 16 per cent annually over the past five years, with occasional increases approaching 28 per cent.
The average annual sugar consumption per person in Pakistan is estimated at 14.76 kilogrammes.
The government has also maintained significant import duties and taxes to discourage foreign sugar purchases. According to the draft policy, the effective protection against sugar imports currently stands at approximately 55 per cent, including customs duties, sales taxes and other levies.
The latest export approval therefore places renewed attention on the government’s responsibility to maintain adequate domestic supplies while allowing producers to access international markets.
ECC Also Relaxes Financing Conditions for Small Businesses
In a separate decision, the ECC approved changes to financing requirements for small and medium enterprises (SMEs) seeking access to Rs50 billion in long-term concessional export financing.
Previously, businesses were required to generate at least 80 per cent of their sales through exports from the beginning of the financing arrangement.
Under the revised conditions, eligible businesses have been exempted from this initial requirement but must achieve exports equivalent to at least 50 per cent of their projected total sales within four years.
The committee also granted a four-year exemption from Pakistan Green Taxonomy compliance requirements for borrowers under the Long Term Export Financing Facility.
The Finance Ministry said the changes were intended to give newly established businesses sufficient time to develop production facilities, establish international markets and secure export orders.
All other eligibility requirements and conditions of the financing facility will remain unchanged.
Source: The Express Tribune, based on reporting by Shahbaz Rana and information from the government’s draft National Policy for Deregulation of the Sugar Sector.