ISLAMABAD: Political tensions between Pakistan’s ruling Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) and its coalition partner, the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP), have intensified after Defence Minister Khawaja Asif made fresh critical remarks about PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari, prompting Senator Sherry Rehman to warn that he had crossed a “red line”.
The latest exchange has raised concerns about growing differences between the two parties, which share power at the federal level. Despite efforts by Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif and President Asif Ali Zardari to ease tensions through dialogue, political leaders from both sides have continued exchanging criticism.
Sherry Rehman Warns Khawaja Asif Over Bilawal Remarks
PPP Vice President and Senator Sherry Rehman strongly criticised Khawaja Asif’s comments about the party and its chairman.
In a post on X on Sunday, Rehman described the defence minister’s remarks as unacceptable and said he had crossed a red line with his comments about the PPP leadership.
Her response followed a series of social media posts by Asif targeting Bilawal and questioning his political positions.
PPP MNA Sharmila Faruqui also condemned what she described as derogatory language against the party’s leadership.
She said political disagreements should be addressed through arguments rather than personal attacks, adding that a senior parliamentarian and federal minister was expected to demonstrate political maturity and respect for public office.
Khawaja Asif Questions Bilawal’s Political Position
The latest controversy began after Asif shared two video clips of Bilawal on November 19.
One clip showed the PPP chairman discussing political consensus and referring to PTI founder Imran Khan as a political prisoner, while the other featured his recent address at the Karachi Press Club.
Commenting on the videos, Asif said he had expected the younger generation of politicians to be more principled than his own generation but had instead found them to be masters of duplicity who frequently changed their positions.
On November 20, the defence minister shared another video of Bilawal discussing his party’s position within the existing political system.
Bilawal had argued that being part of the system did not prevent him from criticising it or suggesting solutions to national problems.
Responding to the remarks, Asif described Bilawal as potentially the biggest beneficiary of the system, questioning how someone could benefit from it while simultaneously criticising its functioning.
He characterised the PPP chairman’s position as political opportunism.
Khawaja Asif Challenges Bilawal Bhutto Over Criticism of Government
Bilawal House Ownership Also Becomes Part of Political Dispute
Asif subsequently brought the ownership and use of Bilawal House in Lahore into the political debate.
Sharing drone footage of the property, he questioned who legally owned the premises, who lived there and how the money used to construct the building had been obtained.
He also questioned whether individuals could claim moral authority if they could not establish the legal ownership of properties associated with them.
PPP leader Nadeem Afzal Chan responded by sharing a video showing party workers gathering at Bilawal House in Lahore. He described the property as a home for PPP workers and challenged Asif to answer the questions being raised about political privilege.
The exchange added another dimension to the growing disagreement between the coalition partners.
Khawaja Asif Questions PPP’s 18-Year Rule in Sindh
The defence minister also criticised the PPP’s performance in Sindh, where the party has governed for approximately 18 years.
On November 22, Asif shared a newspaper column titled “PPP — Three Questions”, which examined the party’s record in the province and questioned whether federal financial transfers had translated into improvements in public services.
Referring to the amount transferred to Sindh, Asif cited Rs18,840 billion and questioned whether anyone would hold the provincial leadership accountable for its performance.
The criticism focused on areas including education, healthcare, infrastructure and basic public services.
These remarks prompted further reactions from PPP figures amid the continuing disagreement over the party’s role in the federal coalition.
Disagreement Started After Bilawal’s Karachi Press Club Speech
The political dispute intensified following Bilawal’s November 17 address at the Karachi Press Club.
During the speech, the PPP chairman criticised aspects of the government’s handling of political and security challenges and called for a political reset.
He also discussed the proposal to create new provinces and warned of potential bloodshed in Sindh if attempts were made to divide the province without political consensus.
His remarks drew criticism from senior PML-N figures and other political leaders, including representatives of the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan and Jamaat-e-Islami.
Several federal ministers also questioned Bilawal’s position on the creation of new provinces and his criticism of the existing political arrangement.
Zardari and Shehbaz Sharif Seek to Resolve Differences Through Dialogue
Amid the escalating exchange, President Asif Ali Zardari and Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif have held meetings to discuss political differences and maintain cooperation between their parties.
The two leaders met on November 14 and again on November 19, with the latter meeting also attended by Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi.
According to the Presidency, both sides agreed that outstanding matters would be resolved through dialogue and mutual consultation.
Meanwhile, Sherry Rehman has urged the government to focus on public issues rather than creating additional political divisions.
She also clarified that Bilawal wanted to prevent bloodshed in Sindh rather than encourage violence.
The continuing disagreement highlights the challenges facing the ruling coalition as both parties attempt to maintain their political positions while cooperating at the federal level.
Source: The Express Tribune, Dawn and statements issued by Senator Sherry Rehman, Sharmila Faruqui and Defence Minister Khawaja Asif.