Rising Government Expenses Leave Pakistan with Less Money for Development

Pakistan's expanding government administrative structure is putting increasing pressure on public finances

Stay Connected, Stay Informed - Follow News Alert on WhatsApp for Real-time Updates!

LAHORE: Pakistan’s expanding government administrative structure is putting increasing pressure on public finances, leaving limited resources for development projects, infrastructure investment and job creation, according to a new research report by the Institute of Cost and Management Accountants of Pakistan (ICMA International).

More than 80% of provincial government expenditure goes towards recurring costs, including salaries, pensions and other operational expenses, while local governments received less than 5% of total government expenditure in 2024. The report has also raised concerns about the effectiveness of existing administrative structures and questioned whether creating additional provinces would improve governance and economic development.

More Than 3.5 Million People Enter Labour Market Every Year

The report, titled ICMA’s Fiscal Vision for Pakistan: Aligning Administrative Structures with Economic Realities, highlights the growing gap between Pakistan’s employment requirements and the government’s ability to support economic activity.

Nearly 3.5 million people enter the country’s labour force every year, creating additional pressure on an economy already struggling to generate sufficient employment opportunities.

According to the report, unemployment among graduates aged between 20 and 24 stands at 32.8%, increasing to 42.3% among women in the same age group.

The figures underline the need for policies that encourage private investment, entrepreneurship and regional economic development rather than relying heavily on government employment.

The report argues that rising administrative expenditure is reducing the fiscal space available for productive investment, particularly at the provincial level.

More Than 80% of Provincial Spending Goes to Recurring Costs

One of the major concerns highlighted in the ICMA report is the growing share of provincial budgets consumed by recurring expenditure.

More than four-fifths of provincial spending goes towards routine government expenses, leaving relatively limited resources for development initiatives.

At the same time, local governments accounted for less than 5% of total government expenditure in 2024.

This raises questions about the financial authority of local institutions, which are directly responsible for addressing many public needs, including municipal services and local infrastructure.

The report suggests that strengthening local government financing could improve service delivery and ensure that public resources are directed towards areas where they are most needed.

However, it also cautions against indiscriminate cuts to recurring expenditure, as these budgets include essential obligations such as education, healthcare, salaries and pensions.

Debate Over Creation of New Provinces

The report has also raised questions about proposals to create additional provinces, arguing that expanding administrative structures without clearly defining responsibilities and financing arrangements could increase government costs.

Industrialist Ali Arif said Pakistan should focus on improving existing administrative institutions rather than automatically adding more layers of government.

He pointed out that businesses already face difficulties dealing with multiple departments, overlapping regulations and lengthy approval procedures.

Arif also expressed concerns that creating additional provinces could introduce more administrative stakeholders and complicate inter-provincial trade and business activities.

The report recommends evaluating governance reforms on the basis of their economic benefits, administrative efficiency and financial sustainability.

Only One Public-Private Partnership Project Reaches Agreement Stage

Pakistan’s difficulties in attracting private investment are also reflected in the slow progress of government-backed public-private partnership projects.

According to the report, the federal government’s public-private partnership pipeline contains 47 projects, including 22 qualified and 25 non-qualified proposals.

However, only one project has reached the concession agreement stage.

The figures highlight challenges in converting proposed infrastructure investments into operational projects.

The report identifies weaknesses in project preparation, technical and financial assessments, and coordination between federal and provincial institutions as important obstacles to progress.

It argues that announcing investment pipelines is not sufficient to attract private capital unless projects are commercially viable and can move through approval procedures efficiently.

Government Jobs Remain Highly Competitive

The pressure on Pakistan’s employment market is also evident in federal recruitment figures.

In 2024, a total of 274,566 applications were received for just 1,722 federal government positions.

The intense competition reflects the continued demand for public-sector employment among graduates seeking financial security.

A former State Bank of Pakistan official cited in the report said investors needed predictable policies, faster approvals and government institutions capable of resolving business-related problems.

The official argued that increasing the number of government offices and departments would not necessarily improve the country’s ability to attract investment.

ICMA Recommends Administrative and Fiscal Reforms

Drawing on administrative and fiscal experiences from seven countries, the ICMA report recommends strengthening existing divisional and district institutions instead of creating additional administrative units without clear economic justification.

Its recommendations include:

Strengthening existing divisional and district-level institutions.

Increasing financial authority and resources for local governments.

Removing overlapping regulations and administrative responsibilities.

Introducing digital approval mechanisms.

Sharing specialised technical resources across different levels of government.

Establishing integrated regulatory frameworks to reduce the compliance burden on businesses.

The report argues that clearer institutional responsibilities and more efficient public administration could improve investment conditions, support entrepreneurship and make public spending more productive.

For Pakistan, where millions of people enter the labour market every year and fiscal resources remain constrained, improving government efficiency is increasingly important.

The central challenge is to ensure that public expenditure supports economic growth, employment generation and better public services rather than simply maintaining an expanding administrative structure.

Source: The Express Tribune, based on the ICMA International report, ICMA’s Fiscal Vision for Pakistan: Aligning Administrative Structures with Economic Realities.

Leave a Comment

This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, redistributed or derived from.
Unless otherwise stated, all content is copyrighted © 2026 News Alert.