Shabbir Jan’s Remarks Spark Industry Debate
Prominent Pakistani television actor Shabbir Jan has questioned the acting credentials of superstar Humayun Saeed, suggesting that despite his fame, Saeed has not yet reached the standards set by the country’s greatest performers.
Speaking during an appearance on a private television channel, Jan acknowledged Saeed’s efforts and dedication but expressed that his acting fails to leave a lasting impression. “Humayun is hardworking and has earned his position with effort,” Jan said. “But his acting still does not inspire me completely.”
The comments have triggered discussion across the entertainment world, as Humayun Saeed remains one of Pakistan’s most bankable stars, credited with revitalising the country’s film industry in recent years.
“More Models Than True Actors”
During the program, Shabbir Jan also voiced concern over what he described as a growing dominance of models over trained actors in Pakistan’s showbiz industry.
He argued that many newcomers rely heavily on their looks rather than investing in character development or emotional depth. “We are seeing more models and fewer real actors,” Jan remarked. “The focus is shifting to physical beauty rather than the craft itself.”
This statement resonated with some industry observers who have long criticised the emphasis on glamour over substance in Pakistani television and cinema. For many fans, however, it came as a surprise since Humayun Saeed’s performances in blockbuster dramas and films are widely celebrated.
Humayun Saeed’s Popularity and Career Milestones
Humayun Saeed, now in his early fifties, is considered one of Pakistan’s most successful actors and producers. Over a career spanning three decades, he has appeared in hit dramas such as Mere Paas Tum Ho and Doraha, and films like Jawani Phir Nahi Ani and Punjab Nahi Jaungi.
His projects have consistently broken viewership and box-office records. For instance, Punjab Nahi Jaungi (2017) became one of Pakistan’s highest-grossing films at the time, crossing more than PKR 500 million in revenue domestically and internationally.
Beyond acting, Saeed also co-founded Six Sigma Plus, a production house behind several successful dramas. His contribution to the revival of Pakistani cinema since the mid-2010s has been widely acknowledged.
Criticism Amid Success
Despite his popularity, Humayun Saeed has often faced criticism for his acting style. Some industry veterans argue that his performances rely heavily on charm and screen presence rather than technical finesse.
Shabbir Jan’s comments are part of this broader debate. By praising Saeed’s work ethic but questioning his artistic depth, Jan highlighted the gap between commercial success and critical acclaim.
Such criticism is not new in the global entertainment industry. In Hollywood and Bollywood alike, commercially successful stars are sometimes accused of prioritising looks and charisma over method acting or versatility.
The Broader Question of Standards in Acting
Shabbir Jan’s remarks also touch on a deeper issue within Pakistan’s entertainment sector: what defines a “great actor”?
For Jan, experience, emotional range, and the ability to disappear into a role are critical qualities. He expressed concern that newer entrants into the industry—many of whom come from a fashion background—are prioritising appearance over the essence of performance.
“Good looks can attract attention,” he explained, “but it is talent that sustains a career and elevates an industry.”
Mixed Reactions from Fans and Industry Insiders
The response to Jan’s critique has been divided. Some fans agreed with his perspective, suggesting that while Humayun Saeed is an icon, he does not demonstrate the same depth as veteran actors like Abid Ali, Rahat Kazmi, or Shakeel.
Others defended Saeed, pointing out that his consistent success reflects audience appreciation, which should be valued as much as critical standards. On social media, many noted that “audience love” and “critical acclaim” are not always the same thing, but both play a role in shaping an actor’s legacy.
An Ongoing Conversation
Shabbir Jan’s critique is unlikely to diminish Humayun Saeed’s star power, but it has reignited a conversation about the balance between glamour and craft in Pakistani show business.
As the entertainment industry continues to evolve, the debate over whether stardom should rest on looks, talent, or a blend of both remains a pressing question. For now, Humayun Saeed remains at the top of his game commercially, while critics like Shabbir Jan call for higher artistic benchmarks.
